Title: The Scientific Sherlock Holmes
Sub Title: Cracking the Case with Science and Forensics
Publisher: Oxford University Press
Pub Date: December 01, 2012
ISBN: 9780199794966
Author: James O’Brien

Marketing Copy: 

One of the most popular and widely known characters in all of fiction, Sherlock Holmes has an enduring appeal based largely on his uncanny ability to make the most remarkable deductions from the most mundane facts. The very first words that Sherlock Holmes ever says to Dr. Watson are, “How are you? You have been in Afghanistan, I perceive.” Watson responds, “How on earth did you know that?” And so a crime-solving legend is born.

In The Scientific Sherlock Holmes, James O’Brien provides an in-depth look at Holmes’s use of science in his investigations. Indeed, one reason for Holmes’s appeal is his frequent use of the scientific method and the vast scientific knowledge which he drew upon to solve mysteries. For instance, in heart of the book, the author reveals that Holmes was a pioneer of forensic science, making use of fingerprinting well before Scotland Yard itself had adopted the method. One of the more appealing aspects of the book is how the author includes real-world background on topics such as handwriting analysis, describing how it was used to capture the New York Zodiac killer and to clinch the case against the Lindbergh baby kidnapper.

Sherlock Holmes was knowledgeable about several sciences, most notably chemistry. Therefore the book takes a close look at Holmes the chemist and discusses, for example, chemical poisons such as carbon monoxide, chloroform, and Prussic acid (the historical name for hydrogen cyanide). The author also debunks Isaac Asimov’s famous assertion that Holmes was a blundering chemist. In addition, the book discusses mathematics, physics, biology, astronomy, meteorology, and geology, always in the context of Holmes’s exploits.

Sherlock Holmes continues to fascinate millions of readers and movie goers alike. The Scientific Sherlock Holmes is a must-read for the legion of fans of this most beloved of all fictional detectives.

My Review:

I loved this book.  It had everything that a nerd/geek like me would want to know about Sherlock Holmes.  It goes into a lot of detail about his techniques, describing each against real cases were the logic has either supported or failed the case and which investigatory techniques have since been debunked.  Amazing.  You will not lack for information here, even though it is relatively short.

But the part of this book, I enjoyed even more was the character building elements Conan Doyle used to make the most famous detective.  Bits of Poe here, bits of school teachers there, to create a the basis for all modern literary detectives.

On the only downside, I found was the odd section that appeared to have bene repeated.  Sometimes, I felt like I’d read similar words only a page or two before, which I found slightly disconcerting.  Otherwise, this is a great read if you like your analysis on the slightly heavier side.


4 deerstalker caps out of 5.